The Rivalry. Northern Spike and Mr. Macho

Derby Trial stretch drive 1980. Northern Spike inside. Mr. Macho outside.

Derby Trial stretch drive 1980. Northern Spike inside. Mr. Macho outside.

by Bob Gates

Mr. Macho and Northern Spike's two-year rivalry at Assiniboia Downs was a classic.

Why just 1979 and 80? Well, after 1980 "Spike" raced at the Downs until May 1984. "Macho" move to Woodbine and Fort Erie in 1981 with "pit stops" at Santa Anita and Arlington Park. He never returned to the Downs. So all we have to go on is 1979 and 80, but what a two-year period that was!

How fair is it to compare these two? The simple answer to that question lies somewhere between "probably not very" and "who knows," but in the horseracing biz, it's what we love to do.

Spike was a Manitoba-bred and Macho was bred in God's Country, aka Ontario. Spike was a sprint specialist who would run on any surface. He excelled at distance up to six furlongs. Macho didn't get his juices going until after he'd gone at least two turns. The further, the better for the grey gelding. Macho's distance of choice was 1 1/8-miles or further. Running surface? Macho loved the turf, but often ran on dirt and had a definite preference for a "fast" racing strip. No mud for this boy.

Northern Spike with Jack Wash up. May 9, 1982. Inaugural Handicap. New Track Record for 5 furlongs. :56.4.

Northern Spike with Jack Wash up. May 9, 1982. Inaugural Handicap. New Track Record for 5 furlongs. :56.4.

Spike set four track records during his career at the Downs. As a three-year-old (1980) he set the record for about seven furlongs. In 1982 he set new marks for four, five and six furlongs. His record romps for four and five furlongs still stand today! His four furlong time of :44 2/5 equaled the world record for a half mile and his five furlong record of :56 2/5 was a Canadian record that stood for many years.  Mr. Macho won many races at the Downs, but there were no track records for him.

Mr. Macho goes to post for the 1980 Manitoba Derby. Irwin Driedger up.

Mr. Macho goes to post for the 1980 Manitoba Derby. Irwin Driedger up.

Spike was a son of the respected sire Northern Hawk.  Macho's claim to fame came from his dam's sire, Stage Door Johnny. Ring any bells?  Stage Door Johnny won the 1968 Belmont Stakes and denied Forward Pass the Triple Crown that year. Macho could run countless 24-second quarters.

In 1980 it appeared that both Macho and Spike had legitimate shots at the Manitoba Derby, but western star Country Free's powerful stretch drive dashed the hopes of our local favourites. Macho finished second and Spike ran third. Irwin Driedger on Mr. Macho lodged a claim of foul against the winner for interference, but it was disallowed.

Spike's excuse? I've heard the story more than once and it goes like this: at the top of the stretch Spike was on the lead and it was his race to lose. Once he was challenged by Macho and Country Free, his rider, Clifford Thompson pulled out his stick and went at Spike hard. Some said it threw the copper-brown bay gelding off his stride and killed his chances of victory. Who knows?

But the classic race for these two fierce competitors came one week before the Derby, in the Manitoba Derby Trial. By any standards you want to use, the race was a pure masterpiece.

The July 25, 1980 match up in the Trial treated almost 6,000 patrons to what amounted to a match race. There are no adjectives to adequately describe the race and the herculean efforts exerted by the two combatants. It was unfair that one of them had to lose.

Macho headed Spike twice in the stretch drive only to see Spike fight back and regain the lead. Then Macho dug deeper and found the place where special horses go when the tank is on empty. The photo finish camera was needed to call the winner and the head-bob went to Macho. What a race, what a stretch drive and what a finish! The real winners that Friday night in July were those who witnessed one of the finest races ever run at that Downs.

That beautiful gray. Mr. Macho.

That beautiful gray. Mr. Macho.

Just a few last stats before wrapping up:

It has been incorrectly reported that Spike was the first Manitoba-bred to win $100,000.  Thanks to Dr. Ross McKague, we know this is wrong. That honour goes to Hasty Rick.  But Hasty Rick never ran at the Downs, and Spike did, so we'll employ the "asterisk" rule and give this "record" to Spike.

Northern Spike with trainer Phil Hayek. A much loved horse.

Northern Spike with trainer Phil Hayek. A much loved horse.

Spike's total career earnings came to $186,902, Macho's bested him slightly at $192,965.  Their respective records at the Downs? Spike went 18-7-8 from 42 starts while Macho went 8-5-1 from 25 starts. In the seven races where Spike and Macho went head to head at the Downs in 1979/80: Spike was in the money 7/7 with a record of 2-2-3, while Macho went 6/7 with a record of 2--3-1.

So who was better?

Northern Spike or Mr. Macho?

The edge in this one goes to _____?_____.

The fans.

4 Responses

  1. Dear Bob,
    This story is as good as it gets, as we know the real stars are the horses. I grew up with Diane, Danny Dowler’s wife, and knew how much Spike meant to their horse crazy daughter. But as you have told in previous stories he was sold and never returned to the family. What happened to Mr. Macho?

    • It’s really hard to say Louise. Dr. Maxwell told me he basically gave Macho away. His racing career went on until 1986. His last race was September 22, 1986 – a handicap race at Fort Erie for an owner by the name of Comra. Like so many others we simply lose track of them, which is sad, but we still remember him.

  2. Wonderful article on those two great horses. The pictures were fantastic. Love the pic of Phil and Northern Spike. Phil was a fantastic trainer and horseman. His horses always came first. We lost a great trainer when Phil changed careers. Was great to see Phil Hayek at track this month presenting a award for a Stakes race.

    • Thanks Leona, I really appreciate your support. And I couldn’t agree more Phil cared very deeply for his horses.

Leave a comment